1. Rev. John B. Hills, 1962-1965
2. Rev. Rob Roy Rudy, 1965-1966
   • Trinity Staff, 1966-1967
3. Rev. Larry G. Smellie, 1967-1971
   • Interim Rev. William E. Martin, 1971-1972
4. Rev. Howell Anderson Jr.,* 1972-1972
5. Rev. W. Kenneth Williams,** 1972-1976
6. Rev. Todd D. Smelser,*** 1976-1981
7. Rev. Raymond E. Dage, 1981-1982
8. Rev. William E. Martin,**** 1982-1986
9. Rev. Harold L. Comer, 1986-1998
   • Interim Rev. James N. Lodwick, 1998-1998
10. Rev. Martin B. Lavengood, 1998-2000
    • Interim Rev. Edgar G. Parrott, 2000-2001
11. Rev. Lloyd W. Johnson, 2001-2006
    • Interim Rev. Margaret G. Harker, 2006-2007
12. Rev. Daniel K. Layden, 2007-

* Died 11/1/72
** St. Albans moved to 7308 St. Joe Rd. 9/1/74
*** Named First Rector in 1979, Fr. Terry Russell, Assistant
**** Died 1/18/86